The Libel against the Jewish people by our own press and politicians called "Settler Violence" and Unique Sites of Israel: Top 10 Archeological Discoveries in Israel from 2021By Nosson Shulman and Angel jokes
Yehuda Lave is an author, journalist, psychologist, rabbi, spiritual teacher, and coach, with degrees in business, psychology and Jewish Law. He works with people from all walks of life and helps them in their search for greater happiness, meaning, business advice on saving money, and spiritual engagement.
The Libel against the Jewish people by our own press and politicians called "Settler Violence"
There are many attempts to delegitimize Israel. There is the charge of "apartheid." And the charge that Israel has committed "genocide." And the charge that Israel is an "occupier." There needn't be truth to these and similar charges; they simply have to be repeated time and again to convince some people to believe them.
Now we see a new charge: "settler violence" and the failure of the Israeli government to deal with it.
This one is a bit different from the other charges, for the primary charge is not directed at all the Jews of Israel. It is directed at "settlers": those Israeli Jews who live in areas over the 1967 armistice line (which doesn't actually exist any longer) in Judea & Samaria. "Settler" – a perfectly honorable word – is being turned into an epithet.
Credit: Avraham Shapira
What we are being told is that within the population of "settlers" there are young men who act violently towards innocent Arabs. Sometimes that is all that is said. There may be a reference to a specific yeshuv (community or "settlement"). Or there may be a reference to "hilltop youth" in small "illegal outposts."
Credit: i24News
We're hearing a lot about it these days – from various elected officials and the Israeli media, and from sources outside of Israel, including – wouldn't you know – from the UN. "Settler violence," we are being told, is a growing and serious problem.
What I am finding as I research this is:
[] Failure to confirm that alleged attacks really happened as reported
[] Failure to put alleged attacks by "settlers" into context
[] Provocation – deliberate stirring up of a situation
[] Attempts to equate the severity of such alleged attacks by "settlers" with attacks on Jews by Palestinian Arabs
[] Attempts to convey the impression having Jews in Judea & Samaria is a problem – this feeds the push to make way for that "two-state solution"
[] Drawing on the alleged "settler" attacks in order to level either implicit or overt criticism against the government and/or the IDF (Civil Administration) for failing to confront them – a piece of what is going on as delegitimization of Israel increases
This posting provides an overview of the situation. Obviously, I cannot examine every instance of a "settler violence" accusation; that would require a book. But I want to begin with one recent accusation that addresses the matter of context.
In late December or early January, it made the news that students of the Homesh Yeshiva threw stones directly outside or within the perimeter of the neighboring Arab village of Burqa. I am having trouble finding news sources because they refer to "settlers" and not specifically Homesh students. In one report, windows in a new house were broken. I have seen no documentation of injury to the Arabs of Burqa by the students of Homesh – no concussions or eye injuries, etc.
Now, I am definitely not someone who endorses stone-throwing. And I recognize that I would be expected to condemn such acts by the yeshiva students of Homesh if indeed they committed them. But I feel the need here to consider the background situation. The yeshiva students of Homesh were grieving, having suffered the loss of one of their own, Yehuda Dimentman (below with his wife and son), in an unprovoked drive-by shooting. Grieving and likely enraged.
Courtesy Dimentman family
But there was not a hint of a suggestion that they were planning a retaliatory shooting of a local Arab, or a knifing. They may have thrown stones.
And so what should we be talking about: "settler violence" or how to stop the murderous attacks by Palestinian Arabs?
~~~~~~~~~~
According to the IDF, in 2021 (as reported in mid-December) Arabs carried out 6,633 attacks in Judea & Samaria: 61 shootings, 18 stabbings, 1,022 fire bombings, 5,532 rock-throwing attacks.
This comes to 18 attacks against Jews in Judea & Samaria per day!
Compared to 2020, the year 2021 showed a 38% increase in stone-throwing incidents, a 36% increase in Molotov cocktail attacks, and twice as many stabbings.
Over and over, my friends, in my postings I have made a point of noting the praiseworthy behavior of Jews in Judea & Samaria when coping with the murder of one of their own. They don't seek vengeance, they want to build in the memory of the person who was killed.
The Jews of Judea & Samaria are in the main dedicated to Zionist ideals. They are not perfect. Some small number might lash out in frustration on occasion. But they should be saluted for their courage in the face of terror and their commitment to their ideals, not vilified. But they are being vilified.
RABBI SCHWARTZ'S TERRIBLE ANGEL JOKES OF THE WEEK
t was tax time in Chelm, and two of its leading citizens were having a discussion.
"I don't understand this business with taxes," said the first man. "Surely the Czar has enough money of his own. He even has his own royal mint, where he can make as many rubles as he likes. So why does he bother with my ruble?"
"Don't be silly," said the second. "Let me tell you a parable. It is said that every time a Jew performs a mitzvah, God creates an angel. So why not ask God why he needs one more angel in addition to the millions of angels he has already created? Can't God make as many angels as he likes? Of course he can! But why doesn't he? Because God prefers your angel.
"Well the same thing is true with taxes. Of course the Czar can make as many rubles as he likes. But you don't understand -- he prefers your ruble."
A community was asked about the qualities of their former rabbi. "He can be compared to Moses, King David, and even an angel," came the response.
The new community eagerly accepted the rabbi as their spiritual leader but quickly realized he was incapable of anything. They wrote a letter to the other community, complaining as to why they deceived them.
To which they received a reply, "We were not deceiving you. Just like Moses — this rabbi can't speak. He knows not a word of English — like King David. And just as an angel — a mentsh he is not."
What did the angel say when it went to heaven? well halo there!
Yankel did an extraordinary act of kindness and in repayment for that Hashem sent down an angel to give him his reward.
The angel tells him "Because you have lived a good and virtuous life, I can offer you a gift: you can be the most handsome man in the world, or you can have infinite wisdom, or you can have limitless wealth."
Reflecting for a minute Yankel says, "I'll take the wisdom"
"Wisdom is yours," says the angel, disappearing in another puff.
The smoke is barely clear before the Yankel then comes to his first brilliant realization, "I should have taken the money."
An angel once visited me but only described the measurements of a triangle to me. It felt like a sine from God
Why do angels smell so good? Because of their scent from God.
What did the angel say to the other angel at the party? Are you heaven a good time?
A quarter dies and goes to heaven At his arrival at the gates of heaven, Hashem himself welcomes him while angels play the trumpets. The quarter doesn't believe his eyes as he is being given the most beautiful cloud of all with riches and food and honey for eternity.
The next day the one-hundred-dollar bill dies. He also rises to heaven but there doesn't appear to be anyone. He pushed the gate open by himself but behind it is nobody but one angel playing on his phone. The one-hundred-dollar bill asks for his cloud but is given a little filthy grey rainy cloud. As he tries to make himself comfortable in which is doesn't succeed, he sees the quarter on his right partying with all the angels at his enormous white cloud.
Upset he goes to Hashem himself to complain.
"Why does the quarter get the best cloud while I get this stormy trash? I'm more valuable, right?", asks the one hundred dollar bill.
Hashem responds: yeah, but you we didn't see that much in Shul….
What do you call an angel that turned evil? A 180° Angel
Unique Sites of Israel: Top 10 Archeological Discoveries in Israel from 2021
In January 2021, archeologists discovered 3 strands of the royal purple dye (called "Argaman" in the Bible) in the Timna valley. In ancient times, this was the world's most valuable dye. Photo Credit: Israel Antiquities Authority
Israel is one huge archeological site! Since just about any location in the country could literally be on top of buried ancient treasure, there is a strictly enforced law. Prior to developers building anything (or before the government can add new infrastructure like widening a highway) archeologists must first excavate the site in order to see what lies beneath the ground. Additionally, because of the sheer volume of archeological sites in Israel (including several not yet discovered) it's not unusual for major archeological finds to be made by individual hikers, and even children during family outings. Besides these finds at previously unknown locations, many sites are already known to be rich with archeology, and when funding for digs (which are very expensive) are secured, sites are dug with the expectation that major finds will be unearthed.
Advertisement
The year 2021 was another fruitful year for archeological discovery. Hundreds of finds were discovered, many quite revolutionary in our understanding of past biblical and historic events. While all of these findings deserve their own articles, I have narrowed down the list to what I believe were the top 10 finds:
Two major Yavne finds:
a) First-ever First Sanhedrin-era building ever to be found in Yavne (circa 1st century CE)
Archeologists excavating the ancient cemetery of Yavne Photo Credit: Yaniv Berman / Israeli Antiques Administration
Yavne is best known to Jews as the first location of the Sanhedrin (the central Rabbinical Supreme Court) after the destruction and exile from Jerusalem. When Israel's eternal capital was under siege by Roman General (and future emperor) Vespasian, Rabban Yochanan ben Zakkai (then head of the Sanhedrin) left the city to meet him. General Vespasian was so impressed with his knowledge that he granted him three wishes, one of which was to allow the restoration of the Sanhedrin in Yavne (which became the world's most important Jewish spiritual center for several decades) in addition to the guaranteed safety of its sages (circa 1st century CE). This may have been the most important (and defining) event in Jewish history and Torah observance in the last 2000 years! With the destruction of the Temple, there were many Torah laws which were now unclear, which the Sages of Yavne clarified. The sages of this great city ensured the continuation of the Jewish people in a post-Temple world!
In 2021, the first ever building found from the Yavne-Sanhedrin era was discovered by chance due to development work on the city's expansion. Inside the building, religious vessels such as "measuring cups" were found entirely made of stone (according to Jewish law, stone vessels do not retain impurity) showing the high level of Torah observance (in ritual purity) practiced in the community. In addition, a cemetery (with elaborate tombs which were carefully spaced out at set distances, suggesting an official body responsible for burial) was discovered outside the city (as is required by Jewish law). Some believe that these tombs may even belong to some of the famous sages known to have been buried in Yavne.
During excavations of Tel Yavne, a massive 1500-year-old winery was discovered, believed to be the largest from the Byzantine era. In this complex were five magnificent wine presses, (each covering an area of 225 m2) four large warehouses for aging and marketing the wine, and kilns for firing the clay amphorae. The winepresses were adorned with decorative niches (which showed the wealth of the factory owners). It is believed that this complex could produce 2 million liters of wine per year (around 2,666,667 bottles). This is even more impressive, considering that the whole process was conducted manually! This wine was considered very prestigious in the ancient world, and excavations in other countries have discovered wine jars from this winery.
2) Crusader Sword (Mediterranean Sea)
900 year old sword which belonged to a mighty knight! Photo Credit: Shlomi Katzin
In October, Shlomi Katzrin was scuba diving near the beaches of Haifa and noticed something unusual. Upon closer look, he saw that it appeared to be an ancient sword, which he handed over to the Israeli Antiquities Authority (as is required according to Israeli law). Examination revealed that they had found a Crusader sword which had belonged to a knight. The sword, sporting a 30 cm hilt and one-meter-long iron blade, was found in perfect condition (although it was encrusted in marine life). He also discovered some ancient metal anchors and pottery.
According to experts, the area (a natural cove near the port city of Haifa) was used as a storm shelter for ancient merchant ships for centuries (leaving behind a rich array of archeological treasures). According to the Israel Antiquities Authority (IAA) the plan is to clean the sword and then display it at a museum.
3) Well-preserved fortress connected to the Chanukah Story (Lachish Forest)
This well-fortified structure was destroyed by the Maccabees (circa 112 BCE) and is connected to the Jewish holiday of Chanukah. Photo Credit: Israel Antiquities Authority
From the time of Alexander the Great (circa 332 BCE) until 167 BCE, the Hellenist Greeks occupied Israel, oppressing the Jewish inhabitants, and trying to force them to abandon the Torah. They even desecrated the holy Temple, turning it into a temple for Zeus. This led to a rebellion led by a small band of pious brothers (all priests) known as the Maccabees who miraculously retook the Temple and purified it in 164 BCE (this rededication of the Temple is celebrated annually by Jews during the 8 days of Chanukah).
After regaining the Temple, the Maccabees expelled the Greeks from the land, gaining the upper hand over the following decades. To protect the important Greek metropolis of Maresha in south central Israel (for more on this world heritage site, click here) a series of forts were built. One of them was discovered and excavated in the Lachish fortress, revealing a well-fortified building 15 x 15 meters (49×49 feet) with a massively thick exterior wall 3 meters (10 feet) wide, sloped in order to prevent scaling. Astonishingly, the ruins are still well preserved to an exceptional height of 2 meters (6.5 feet). It is believed that the original height was 5 meters. As a symbolic bonus, this find was revealed to the public mere days before Chanukah 2021. For more on this incredible find, click here.
4) 2000-year-old coin minted by the Temple Mount Plaza (Jerusalem)
The extremely rare silver coin (likely minted by the Temple) was found by an 11-year girl. Photo Credit: ELIYAHU YANAI/CITY OF DAVID
One of the sites I really enjoy visiting with my tourists is the Emek Tzurim sifting project in Jerusalem. In 1999, the ancient treasures of the Temple Mount were loaded onto trucks and dumped in the Kidron Valley by the Muslim Waqf who control the site. As the dirt taken from the holiest site in Judaism was highly likely to contain important archeological finds, a sifting project open to tourists was initiated to salvage the archeology, giving children and adults alike the opportunity to find earth shattering discoveries!
In November 2021, an 11-year-old girl, Liel Krutokop, sifted through the dirt and found an (almost) 2000-year-old coin made out of pure silver. Weighing 14 grams, it is believed that the coin was minted by Kohanim (priests) using the large silver reserves of the Second Temple in the second year of the Great Jewish Revolt (circa 67-68 CE) against the Romans. This is when the Jews briefly expelled the Romans and gained independence for a very short time. Minting currency was one way to assert sovereignty. One side of the coin has an engraving of an image of a cup with the inscription "Israeli Shekel" and the Hebrew letters of "Shin" and "Bet" which is shorthand for "second year". The other side has an engraving of the headquarters of the High Priest and the words "Holy Jerusalem". Ultimately, the rebels were defeated by Rome and the Temple was destroyed in 70 CE.
According to archeologists, this is one of the only items found which was manufactured at this Holy site. For a sample itinerary which includes the sifting project, click here.
5) One of the world's oldest toilette bowls ever found (Jerusalem)
The 2700-year-old toilette may have belonged to one of the Biblical kings such as Hezekiah or Josiah.Photo Credit: Israel Antiquities Authority (Yoli Schwartz)
Archeologists excavating the ruins of a Biblical era Royal palace were stunned when they found an (extremely rare) item which illustrated the immense wealth of its ancient owner, a private bathroom. Inside, a carved limestone toilette was found with a hole in the center, positioned over a deep septic tank. Evidence was also unearthed that a luscious garden with fruit trees and other plants surrounded the toilette (although unfathomable to westerners today, toilettes were such a status of wealth, that making its surroundings beautiful made sense). This is all the more astounding when one considers that even today (according to UNICEF) 60% of the world's population does not have access to proper toilet facilities.
6) Second Synagogue from 2nd Temple period era in Migdal (Magdala)
View of the modern town of Migdal (in blue) and its ancient location (in red) where a rare Second Temple era synagogue was unearthed. Credit: Shutterstock
Over the years during excavations of ancient Jewish settlements that existed in Israel post-Second Temple (70 CE and onwards) many, many synagogues have been discovered (several a must see for tourists). Synagogues from the Second Temple period however, are extremely rare and only 7 have ever been found (including at Masada, Herodium, Etri, Gamla, Modiin, Kiryat Sefer and Migdal (Magdala)). Despite the plethora of ancient Jewish texts stating that synagogues were a fact of life even when the Temple stood, many modern-day (secular) archeologists overlooked these sources. They assumed that when the Temple stood, synagogues didn't play a large role in daily life, being that very few synagogues from this period were found.
In 2021, during the widening of highway 90 (Israel's longest highway) a second temple era synagogue was found in Magdala, making this the first time that two synagogues from this period were found in the same town (the first was found in 2009. I highly recommend anyone visiting Israel to explore this awesome site). The fact that they were a mere 200 meters from each other (one in a residential area, the other industrial) is now making several academics hypothesize that synagogues were indeed an important part of the social fabric at the time!
7) New Dead Sea Scrolls Unearthed (Judean Desert)
The first "new" Dead Sea Scrolls discovered since 1956 were Biblical verses from the Book of Zechariah and Nahum. These scrolls were written in Greek. Photo Credit: Shai Halevi, Israel Antiquities Authority.
Since the Dead Sea scrolls were discovered in 1947, it can be argued that no other archeological findings have captured the public imagination quite like these ones. In fact, the Indiana Jones series was loosely based on a real-life adventurer named Vendyl Jones whose life work revolved around finding treasures mentioned in one of the scrolls. Between 1947 and 1956 many ancient scrolls were discovered, including the entire book of Isaiah, the oldest complete Biblical scroll ever found. While archeologists were exploring the caves of Qumran, local Bedouins were also hard at work finding scrolls to be sold for a fortune on the black market (often, official digs would uncover empty jars standing side by side with Bedouin pickaxes, with the scrolls long gone). After more than a half a century of digs failing to unearth any new scrolls, new discoveries were not expected to be made again.
Recently, excavations began in a cave at Nachal Hever (which is only accessible by rappelling 80 meters down a sheer cliff). Due to its inaccessibility to potential looters, it was hoped that new scrolls would be found. In 2021, it was announced that two scroll fragments were located. One was from Zechariah 8:16-17, and the other Nahum 1: 5-6. In addition, one of the world's oldest woven baskets was found in near perfect condition. For more on these incredible finds, click here.
8) Biblical Era "Royal Purple" Dye (Timna Valley)
A banded Murex, one of the ocean snails used in the production of the valuable "Argaman" dye mentioned several times in the Bible. Photo Credit: Shutter Stock / Alexey Masliy
For the first time ever, the famous "Argaman" royal purple dye (mentioned several times in the Bible) has been found from the times of King David and Solomon. Prior to this, the earliest finds had only been from the Roman Period, approximately 1000 years later. Archeologists digging the famous "Slave Hill" in the Timna Valley (near Eilat) came across three textile scraps with the dye that only the wealthiest could afford (considerably more valuable than gold). Indeed, its Biblical references are usually used in connection with royalty and nobility (see Song of Songs 3:10, Proverbs 31:22, Esther 1:6, and Ezekiel 27:7). This dye was also used to dye curtains in the Tabernacle (see Exodus 25-27).
The purple dye is pigment from the mucus of three species of Murex snails found in the Mediterranean Sea. Archeologists believe that the discovery was made possible due to the dry desert heat in the arid Timna Valley.
9) Inscription of well-known Biblical Prophet (Judean Lowlands)
The 3100-year-old inscription was written on a jug in ink, using ancient Canaanite letters. Photo Credit: DAFNA GAZIT/ISRAEL ANTIQUITIES AUTHORITY
Even in Israel where archeologically significant finds are common, ancient inscriptions from the times of the biblical Judges are exceedingly rare. Recent excavations however, unearthed a name belonging to an important Biblical hero (and prophet).
On a jar more than 3 millennia old, the name "Jerubbaal" was inscribed, another name for the Biblical judge Gideon (it was common for ancient Israelites to have more than one name) who led the Israelites for 40 years and gave them quiet from their enemies (see Judges 7:1 and 8:28).
The million-dollar question is, was this "Jerubbaal" indeed Gideon? Obviously, no one can say with absolute certainty, but archeologists seem convinced that it is a very distinct possibility. Except for in the Bible, "Jerubbaal" has never been found anywhere until this discovery, suggesting that it was an uncommon name. It is also dated from around the time of Judges when Gideon led Israel. For more on this fabulous find, click here.
10) Evidence of Biblical Earthquake Discovered in Jerusalem (City of David)
Recent digs in Jerusalem's City of David uncovered an 8th century BCE destruction layer, caused by an earthquake mentioned in the Bible. Photo Credit: Joe Uziel, Israel Antiquities Authority
For the first time ever, archeological remains of a catastrophic earthquake mentioned in the Bible were discovered in Jerusalem.
An 8th century BCE destruction layer was unearthed with a smashed building, and a row of shattered vessels. While destruction layers have been found in Jerusalem, especially in connection with the Babylonian destruction of Jerusalem in 422 BCE (some historians say 586 BCE) all of them had burn marks, which suggested destruction by fire. This one had only collapsed walls, suggesting that it was not deliberate, but rather caused by natural forces. Archeologists were stunned and decided to consult the Bible to see if such an event was mentioned. They soon found references to a massive earthquake mentioned in both Amos 1:1 and Zechariah 14:5 as having taken place during the reign of King Uzziah (indeed, the destroyed building is dated to that period). For more on this incredible discovery, click here.
